Best Sites To Buy And Sell Trading Cards In Canada

If you collect in Canada, you've got options, lots of them. But the right place to buy or sell depends on what you're moving, how fast you need to move it, and how much you're willing to pay in fees. As collectors who run CardChasers, we live this every day, online, in-store, and live on stream, so this guide zeroes in on the best sites to buy and sell trading cards in Canada, with practical tips that actually save you money and time. You'll find where to list singles, where to consign slabs, how to ship without headaches, and how to avoid the classic Canadian pitfalls like brokerage fees and mismatched sales taxes. If you've ever Googled "shop best sites sell trading cards Canada" and felt overwhelmed, this is the clear, no-BS breakdown you've been looking for.

How To Choose The Right Marketplace In Canada

Before you pick a platform, get specific about your situation. The right marketplace in Canada depends on four things:

  • What you're selling or buying: TCG bulk, graded slabs, wax, or raw singles? Hockey vs Pokémon vs MTG change the playbook.

  • Speed vs. payout: Need fast cash (local sale) or top dollar (consignment or auction timing)?

  • Risk tolerance: Do you want buyer protection and a paper trail, or a quick meet-up with less friction?

  • Fees and shipping: Fees can eat 10–20%. Shipping makes or breaks low-value cards.

Quick rules of thumb:

  • Under $25 singles: Local (Facebook, Kijiji) or plain white envelope (PWE)/Lettermail sales with clear terms.

  • $25–$200: eBay Canada for reach and protection: Facebook groups if you've built reputation.

  • $200+ or gradable: Auction/consignment (SlabSharks, COMC) or time eBay auctions with comps.

  • Sealed product: Trusted Canadian shops with sealed case sources and real inventory.

Also ask: how does the platform handle GST/HST/QST? Many marketplaces now collect taxes at checkout, which can make your item seem pricier but keeps you compliant. Finally, think community. A good marketplace is also a good network, deals, trades, and repeat buyers flow from trust.

As for us at CardChasers: if you want help sourcing a specific card or product, or you want to move a card through a hype-driven live stream, we've got you covered daily on TikTok and Whatnot. You can always browse our in-stock selection via our online store collection or jump into our live breaks on Whatnot.

Best All-In-One Marketplaces For Canadians

These are the broad marketplaces where you can list almost anything, raw singles, slabs, sealed, even memorabilia. They're not card-only platforms, but their audience is massive.

eBay Canada

For maximum reach and discoverability, eBay is still the default. You get buyer/seller protections, robust search traffic, and the best comp data in the hobby. Tips:

  • Use precise titles: Year, set, player/character, numbering, parallel, condition.

  • Always check recent "Sold" comps: avoid pricing off Active listings.

  • Auction timing matters: end around Sunday evening ET and avoid major sports events.

  • For lower-value cards, build multi-quantity listings or combine shipping to make the economics work.

Fees: Expect roughly 12–15% all-in after final value fee + payment processing. eBay often collects GST/HST/QST at checkout for Canadian buyers as a marketplace facilitator, which is normal.

Facebook Marketplace And Groups

Local deals, low fees, and fast flips. Use province- or game-specific groups (e.g., Pokémon Canada buy/sell/trade, MTG Ontario, hockey collectors groups). Credibility is everything here, post timestamps, vouches, and ship with clear proof. Great for:

  • Under-$30 singles via Lettermail

  • Local sealed deals

  • Trades and lot sales

Caution: Always use safe payment methods (see below) and meet in public spots with cameras if going in-person. Bring exact change: verify condition on the spot.

Kijiji

Old-school but effective for local pickups of sealed product, collections, or bulk. It's less curated than Facebook groups, so expect more haggling and more tire-kicking. Write clear listings, add plenty of photos, and state "cash only" or your accepted payment method.

Reddit Trading Communities

Subreddits like r/CanadianGamingSales, r/hardwareswapcanada (for accessories), and game-specific trading subs can be excellent for niche items. Reputation (flair) matters. Read each sub's rules carefully, especially around timestamps and shipping proofs. Prices are usually tighter to comps than on Facebook.

Top Canadian Online Card Shops For TCG

Prefer to buy from reputable Canadian shops with fast shipping and legit sourcing? These stores are strong options for sealed and singles across Pokémon, MTG, Yu-Gi-Oh., Lorcana, and more. And yes, if you want the full CardChasers experience, you can browse our store collection or visit us in Laval. We're live every day, and we chase big hits so you don't have to.

Face To Face Games

A national heavyweight with multiple locations. Deep singles inventory for MTG and Pokémon, strong organized play presence, and frequent deals. Great for building decks and filling sets.

401 Games

Toronto-based, competitive pricing, and reliable preorders. Consistent stock on new releases and accessories. Their online experience is straightforward and quick.

Zephyr Epic

Well-known for sealed product, especially Pokémon and hockey, and regular coupon codes. Good for bundling sealed orders with tracked shipping.

Fusion Gaming

Winnipeg-based, solid MTG and Pokémon selection, plus buying lists for those looking to sell in bulk. They're efficient with shipping and inventory updates.

Magic Stronghold

Vancouver favorite with deep MTG roots and a growing TCG lineup. Handy for West Coast collectors who want faster local delivery.

A quick note from us: CardChasers isn't just retail, we're community-first. If you want in on the energy, hop into our Whatnot breaks. If you're hunting something specific, tell us, we'll track it down.

Where To Sell And Auction High-Value Cards In Canada

When you're moving a $300+ slab or a grail-level raw, eyeballs and trust win. These are the best Canadian-accessible options.

SlabSharks Auctions

A Canadian-based consignment and auction service that's built a big buyer pool for slabs and higher-end raw. Pros: strong marketing, themed auctions, and Canadian-friendly logistics. Consignment fees vary with services (cleaning, imaging, etc.), but the visibility often offsets the cost.

COMC Consignment And Sales

COMC (Check Out My Cards) is a powerhouse for time-rich sellers. You ship to COMC, they scan, store, and list your cards: buyers purchase on-platform or via their eBay integration. You can set prices, run promos, or liquidate. Pros: no individual shipping grind: global reach. Cons: processing time and cash-out fees can add up. Many Canadian sellers use COMC to avoid constant post office runs.

eBay Authenticity And Auction Strategies

For raw and graded cards, eBay remains king for auction reach. While specific authenticity programs may vary by category and region, you still benefit from large buyer confidence and seller protections when you list correctly. Strategy pointers:

  • Use 7–10 high-quality photos, including corners, edges, and a clear back shot.

  • Open auctions for high-demand cards: use fixed-price with Best Offer for niche pieces.

  • End auctions during prime hours (Sun 7–10 pm ET) and avoid major game finales.

  • If you're nervous about condition debates, consider grading first (more below) or consigning to SlabSharks/COMC.

Best Sites For Sports Cards And Hockey In Canada

For hockey and other sports, the ecosystem shifts slightly. Here's where Canadians get the best results.

COMC

COMC shines for sports singles, especially mid-end inserts, parallels, and numbered cards. It's fantastic for set builders. You can flip on-platform without ever touching the card, or request shipment when you're ready.

Upper Deck ePack

Upper Deck's ePack lets you open packs digitally that correspond to physical cards you can later combine or have shipped. It's a fun way to chase Young Guns and special inserts without hunting boxes in the wild. Canadians can participate directly, making it a staple for hockey collectors.

eBay Canada For Singles And Slabs

From Young Guns to Cup RPAs, eBay Canada delivers the widest buyer base. Use saved searches, follow sellers you trust, and run 30-day BIN/Best Offer for consistent sales. For very high-end hockey, pair eBay with a Canadian-focused auction house to maximize visibility.

Grading, Submission, And Vault Options Accessible From Canada

Grading changes the value equation, especially for modern hits and condition-sensitive classics. If you're not sure whether to grade, check comps of raw vs graded at your target grade, sometimes the fee doesn't pay off.

PSA, CGC, And BGS Via Canadian Group Submitters

You can submit directly to PSA, CGC, or BGS, or use a reputable Canadian group submitter for consolidated shipping and paperwork help. Group submitters batch cards to lower shipping and sometimes secure better turnaround tiers. If you want a smooth, full-service path, we offer guidance through our own grading page. We'll help you evaluate condition, pick the right service level, and avoid avoidable upcharges.

Prep tips:

  • Clean gently (microfiber only), use card savers, and tab top loaders for easy handling.

  • Photograph before sending. Document surface flaws so there are no surprises.

  • Be realistic: a strong PSA 9 can sell faster and more consistently than a borderline 10 gamble.

COMC Vaulting And Cross-Border Solutions

COMC effectively acts like a vault and marketplace in one. You can buy on COMC, keep items stored, re-list instantly, or have them shipped to Canada when you've built a batch. For cross-border buyers, this reduces repeat brokerage and spreads shipping costs over a larger order. It's especially handy if you're flipping into other cards rather than constantly cashing out.

Fees, Shipping, And Taxes: What Canadians Should Know

The math matters. Between marketplace fees, shipping, and taxes, your take-home can swing wildly.

Marketplace And Consignment Fees

  • eBay: Roughly 12–15% blended after final value fees and payment processing. Promoted listings add cost but can move inventory faster.

  • Facebook/Kijiji/Reddit: Platform fees are essentially zero, but you bear payment risk if you skip protection. Price in your time and potential disputes.

  • SlabSharks: Consignment + selling fees vary by service level: expect a percentage of the final sale.

  • COMC: Ingest (per card) + storage + cashout fees. Great for volume, less ideal for one-and-done flips.

Build a fee spreadsheet. For a $300 card, a 3–5% difference in fees is real money.

Canada Post, Lettermail, And Tracked Options

  • PWE/Lettermail: Cheapest for <$20–$30 cards. Use a penny sleeve + toploader + team bag + painter's tape, then a semi-rigid mailer or cardboard sandwich. Non-machinable stamps help prevent damage. No tracking, so be clear on buyer risk.

  • Lettermail with oversize: Can fit multiple cards: still no tracking. Communicate timelines, domestic mail can vary by region.

  • Tracked parcel: Expedited Parcel is the baseline: Xpresspost if urgent. Use bubble mailers or boxes, and photograph weigh-ins and label.

  • International: Tracked is highly recommended. Declare contents accurately. Some destinations are slower, set expectations.

Pro tip: Combine orders. Offer "free shipping over $20/$50" to nudge multi-card carts and keep your per-card shipping cost low.

Cross-Border Duties, GST/HST, And Brokerage

  • Domestic purchases: Many marketplaces collect GST/HST/QST at checkout: as a seller, that's usually handled for you on-platform.

  • Imports by courier (from the U.S.): Under CUSMA, de minimis thresholds are higher for couriers, generally duty-free up to CAD $150 and tax-free up to CAD $40, but taxes can still apply above those amounts. Brokerage fees depend on the courier and service level.

  • Imports by postal service: The old $20 CAD de minimis often applies: GST/HST and handling fees may be charged on arrival.

When selling to U.S. buyers, fill customs forms cleanly and describe items as "collectible trading cards." Avoid inflated declared values, it hurts your buyer and increases the chance of returns or refusals.

Safe Payments And Trade Etiquette In Canada

Getting paid safely is as important as getting paid fast. Here's how to keep deals clean and your reputation spotless.

PayPal Goods & Services Versus Friends & Family

  • Goods & Services (G&S): Buyer and seller protection, dispute mechanisms, and a fee. For shipped items to strangers, this is the standard. Build the fee into your price.

  • Friends & Family (F&F): No fees but no protection. Best reserved for trusted local deals or established relationships where both sides are comfortable.

Include: item description, agreed condition, shipping method, and timeline in your chat log or invoice. It's boring until it saves you.

Interac E-Transfer Best Practices

Interac is a Canadian staple for local sales. Use auto-deposit when possible to avoid the security question risk. For shipped items, combine Interac with tracked shipping and photo/video proof. Keep screenshots of the conversation, address, and mailing receipt.

Safe Local Meetups And Shipping Proofs

  • Meet in public, well-lit spots, mall food courts or police station exchange zones.

  • Count cash discreetly: use a counterfeit pen for bigger deals.

  • For shipping, photograph the packed item, the labeled package on the scale, and the Canada Post receipt or tracking page. Share the tracking number promptly and manage expectations on delivery windows.

Pricing And Market Data Tools For Canadians

You make money when you buy right. Use multiple data points to avoid chasing inflated asks.

eBay Sold Listings And 130Point

  • eBay sold listings: Filter to "Sold" and "Completed" to see real transaction prices. Narrow by condition and format (auction vs BIN) to get true comps.

  • 130Point: Helpful for seeing accepted Best Offer prices that don't display on eBay item pages. It's not perfect, but it gives you a clearer range.

TCGplayer And Card-Specific Price Trackers

  • TCGplayer: Even if you're in Canada, TCGplayer market prices are a useful reference for Pokémon/MTG/Yu-Gi-Oh.. Always convert currency and factor shipping to Canada.

  • MTG-specific: MTGGoldfish and Scryfall price aggregates.

  • Pokémon-specific: PokéData, PriceCharting for older sets.

  • Sports: Card Ladder and Market Movers for graded comps and index trends.

Cross-verify at least two sources, then sanity-check against Canadian availability (if it's rare domestically, you might pay a premium). If you need a real-time gut check, swing by our shop or ping us during our live breaks, we talk pricing live every day.

Conclusion

If you collect in Canada, you don't have to choose just one lane. Use eBay for reach, Facebook/Kijiji for speed, COMC for scale, and SlabSharks for high-visibility auctions. Buy sealed from reputable Canadian shops to avoid headaches, and grade smart, only when the spread makes sense. Keep your shipping tight, your payments protected, and your comps current.

And if you want a partner in the chase, we're right here. At CardChasers, we're live daily, we stock what the Canadian hobby actually wants, and we help with grading, sourcing, and framing. Start by browsing our store, tap into our Whatnot breaks, or get submission help via our grading page. Or just drop by in Laval, we're open seven days because the chase never stops. You can always learn more about us on our homepage.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the best sites to sell trading cards in Canada?

For broad reach, eBay Canada is the default. For speed and low fees, use Facebook groups or Kijiji for local deals. For $200+ or gradable cards, SlabSharks and COMC excel via consignment and visibility. Match platform to value, speed, and risk tolerance for the best outcome.

How do fees and taxes work when selling trading cards in Canada?

Expect around 12–15% blended fees on eBay Canada. Facebook, Kijiji, and Reddit have near-zero platform fees but higher payment risk. COMC adds ingest, storage, and cash-out fees. Many marketplaces collect GST/HST/QST at checkout, which can make listings appear pricier but keeps you compliant.

What’s the best way to ship cheap singles within Canada?

Use Lettermail (PWE) for sub-$20–$30 cards: penny sleeve, toploader, team bag, cardboard support, and non‑machinable postage. There’s no tracking, so set expectations clearly. For pricier items, use tracked Expedited Parcel or Xpresspost. Combine orders to lower per‑card shipping costs.

Is TCGplayer a good option for Canadians, or should I shop the best Canadian sites instead?

TCGplayer is great for price references, but it’s US‑centric; cross‑border shipping, taxes, and brokerage can add up. Many Canadians prefer trusted local shops like Face to Face Games, 401 Games, Zephyr Epic, Fusion Gaming, and Magic Stronghold for reliable stock, pricing, and faster domestic shipping.

When is the best time to auction cards for top dollar in Canada?

End eBay auctions on Sunday evenings (7–10 pm ET) to capture peak traffic. Avoid major game finales. For sports, time listings around player heat, playoffs, or milestone news. For TCG, ride release weekends or meta shifts. High‑end items often do best via SlabSharks or COMC visibility.

Which Canadian shops are best to buy sealed product and singles?

Top choices include Face to Face Games (deep singles, events), 401 Games (competitive pricing, preorders), Zephyr Epic (sealed, coupons), Fusion Gaming (solid MTG/Pokémon, buy lists), and Magic Stronghold (West Coast favorite). These Canadian shops provide legit sourcing and fast domestic shipping.

Read next

Back to blog